Skip to content
Back to Blog
Loyalty Tips

How to set up loyalty rewards that work: value, cost and threshold

How to set up loyalty rewards that work: the give back rate formula, worked examples for a café, a salon and a shop, and perceived value versus real cost.

Roman Osadský
Roman Osadský7 min read
How to set up loyalty rewards that work: value, cost and threshold

You set a loyalty reward with two numbers: what it costs you, and how much a customer has to spend to earn it. One divided by the other is the give back rate: reward cost ÷ spend needed to earn it. You can work it out in five minutes before you publish the card. A good reward has a low rate for you and a high value in the customer's eyes.

This guide covers value and threshold. How many stamps to put on a card is worked out in how many stamps on a loyalty card, and ideas for what to give are in 7 loyalty reward ideas that work.

The formula: two prices for one reward

Price every reward twice.

  • Menu price: what the customer would pay for it.
  • Your cost: what it really costs you. Ingredients, stock, materials and, for a service, staff time.

That gives two rates:

  1. Worst case = menu price ÷ spend needed. The customer would have come anyway, so you give up the whole sale.
  2. Best case = your cost ÷ spend needed. The card brought a visit that would not have happened, so the reward costs you only what you put into it.

Reality sits between the two. Design the reward so you survive the worst case and enjoy anything better. As a starting range to test (our rule of thumb, not research): a worst case between 5 and 10% of spend.

Three examples: café, salon, shop

All numbers are illustrative, so replace them with yours. Prices and costs are made up, and the 50% margin in the shop is an assumption.

Café, stamp card. The average ticket is €4.50. The card has 8 stamps, one per visit. The reward is a coffee that sells for €3.20 and costs you €0.70.

  1. Spend needed: 8 × €4.50 = €36.
  2. Worst case: €3.20 ÷ €36 = 8.9%.
  3. Best case: €0.70 ÷ €36 = 1.9%.

The customer sees a €3.20 coffee and you pay €0.70. The reward feels about 4.6 times bigger than it costs.

Salon, points card. An average appointment is €45. The card gives 1 point per euro (you can set 1 to 50 points per euro). The reward is an add on treatment priced at €15 that costs the salon €4.50 in products and time. The threshold is 180 points.

  1. Spend needed: 180 points is four visits at €45, so €180.
  2. Worst case: €15 ÷ €180 = 8.3%.
  3. Best case: €4.50 ÷ €180 = 2.5%.

Why four visits and not ten? In Rewardly's data a returning beauty, nails and fitness member waits a median of 27 days for the second visit (how soon members come back). Four visits are three such gaps: 3 × 27 = 81 days, about 12 weeks. Ten visits would be 9 × 27 = 243 days, eight months.

Shop, cashback. The average basket is €28. 5% of every purchase comes back as credit to spend with you.

  1. Credit per purchase: 5% of €28 = €1.40.
  2. Worst case: 5.0%, because the credit is worth its face value, €1.40.
  3. Best case at a 50% margin: goods worth €1.40 cost you €0.70, so 2.5%.

Cashback is the easiest to explain, but it leaves the smallest gap between price and cost (a factor of two at a 50% margin). A shop with higher margin goods could hand out a small item priced at €10 that costs €4 instead.

Business

Worst case

Best case

Café, 8 stamps

8.9%

1.9%

Salon, 180 points

8.3%

2.5%

Shop, 5% cashback

5.0%

2.5%

Perceived value is not cost

The customer does not see your cost. They see the price they would otherwise pay. So the best reward looks big and costs little.

  • An item with a high price and a low cost. A coffee, a croissant, an add on treatment. The €3.20 coffee that costs €0.70.
  • An upgrade instead of a discount. A bigger drink or a free extra looks generous and costs pennies.
  • A percentage discount. The cost equals the discount on every purchase, including the ones that would have happened anyway.
  • Credit. Pure face value. Easy to understand, but no gap between price and cost.

Watch the opposite too. A reward that costs a lot and does not look big is the worst deal, for example a main course with €5 of ingredients offered as a "bonus".

The threshold: how many visits to the first reward

Work out the threshold in euros like this: visits to the reward × average ticket. Choose the number of visits from how often your regular comes. The rule of thumb from our stamp article (not research): a card should fill in roughly 4 to 8 weeks. Someone who visits twice a week fills eight visits in four weeks. For a service with a monthly rhythm, four to six visits are enough.

Make the first reward come early and let the later ones sit further out. On a points card that means several rewards at different prices, for example 100 points for a coffee and 250 for a cake. The customer gets something quickly and the bigger prize keeps them coming.

Before you publish, test the setting on your own data. Take your last 20 receipts and count how many of those customers would have reached the reward in eight weeks. If hardly one would, the threshold is too far away.

One sentence for the rule

If staff cannot explain a reward in one sentence, the customer will not understand it. The pattern is "collect X, get Y".

"Eight coffees and the ninth is free."
"A point for every euro, and 180 points get you a free add on treatment."

The sentence holds three things: what counts (a visit, a product, a euro), when the reward arrives and what the customer gets. A stamp can be given per visit or per product, as stamp per visit or stamp per product explains.

What to watch after launch

Watch three numbers:

  1. How many members came back a second time. In Rewardly's data (more than 40,000 cards across 50+ businesses), 42.5% of new members come back within 30 days and 56.0% within 90. Use that as a yardstick, not a target.
  2. How many cards filled up. If almost none have after eight weeks, the threshold is too far away for your customers.
  3. How many rewards you handed out. Multiply by the cost of one reward. That is what the program costs you each month. How much a digital loyalty program costs shows how to compare it with the price of the plan.

Rewardly clients report 30% more repeat visits, but your own second visit rate is the number to manage. You can draft the card in the free loyalty card maker.

FAQ

How much should a loyalty reward cost?

Work out both rates, worst case and best case. As a starting range, keep the worst case (menu price ÷ spend needed) at roughly 5 to 10% of spend. That is our rule of thumb to test, not research. If yours is higher, shrink the reward or raise the spend needed to earn it.

What is a good reward for a loyalty program?

Something that looks valuable and costs you little: a coffee, a pastry, an add on treatment, an upgrade. Discounts and credit are simpler, but they leave the smallest gap between price and cost. Ideas by trade are in 7 loyalty reward ideas that work.

Is a free item better than a discount?

At the same menu price for the customer, a free item is cheaper for you if its cost is low. A discount costs you what you give away on every purchase. Calculate both with the formula above.

How many stamps should a loyalty card have?

It depends on how often your regular comes. The calculation is in how many stamps on a loyalty card.

Set up your reward and launch the card. Try Rewardly for €0

No upfront payment, 14 days free.

Share this article

Roman Osadský

Written by

Roman Osadský

Co-founder, Rewardly

Continue Reading