How to choose loyalty software: 10 criteria and a scorecard for small business
How to choose loyalty software for a small business: 10 criteria, a 1 to 3 scorecard and honest answers on joining, staff speed, cost and contract.

Score every loyalty system you are considering from 1 to 3 on ten criteria, name two or three as must haves before you start, and drop any tool that scores 1 on a must have. A total of 24 or more out of 30 is a strong fit, 18 to 23 is workable if you know the weak spots, and under 18 means keep looking. The thresholds are our rule of thumb, not an industry standard. Each criterion below has a test you can run in an afternoon, and a plain statement of how Rewardly scores on it, limits included.
This is a method, not a ranking. It names no other vendor, so you can apply it to any tool, ours too.
How to use the scorecard
Copy the table below and add one column per tool. Score from 1 to 3:
- 3: the criterion is met in a way you could show a customer or a new employee.
- 2: it works, with a limit you can live with.
- 1: it fails your test or the vendor cannot show it.
Score only what you have seen. A promise in a sales call is worth a 1 until you have tested it, and a trial is the place to test. Start from a trial or demo account with your own phone and one team member who is not a fan of new tools.
# | Criterion | Rewardly scores |
|---|---|---|
1 | Joining without an app | 3 |
2 | Staff speed at the till | 3 |
3 | Fit with your till | 3 or 2 |
4 | Messages to customers | 2 |
5 | Customer data export | 2 |
6 | Cost model | 3 |
7 | Contract and cancelling | 2 |
8 | Support | 2 |
9 | Languages | 2 |
10 | Analytics | 2 |
That adds up to 24 of 30 on our own scale. It is a statement of facts about our own product, so do not take it as a verdict. Score us yourself with the tests below. The reasons for each number follow.
1. Joining without an app
Test: scan the join QR code with your own phone and time it.
- 3: the card is on the phone in seconds, with no app and no password.
- 2: it works in a browser but asks for an account.
- 1: the customer has to download an app first.
Rewardly: 3. Customers scan a QR code or open a link, fill in a short form (first name and email are recommended, not required) and add the card to Apple Wallet or Google Wallet in about 10 seconds. The limit: the signup always ends in one of the two wallets, and there is no web only card for a phone without one. On a desktop the join page shows only a QR code to scan with the phone. If you have to pick between an app and a wallet card, loyalty app vs wallet has the argument.
2. Staff speed at the till
Test: hand the staff tool to your least patient team member and time how long adding one stamp takes.
- 3: a few seconds, no training beyond one minute of showing.
- 2: it works but needs several taps or a search.
- 1: staff skip it at rush hour.
Rewardly: 3, on a stable connection. The scanner runs in the browser on a phone or tablet, with nothing to install. Staff scan the customer's card and tap to add a stamp, or type the purchase amount on a points card. The limit: it needs an internet connection. A scan made offline is not recorded, so staff scan again once the connection is back. If your wifi drops often, score us 2.
3. Fit with your till
Test: ask which till software the tool connects to, on which plan, and what staff do at the till.
- 3: it connects to your till and staff do not enter the amount twice.
- 2: it works next to your till through a scanner or a manual step.
- 1: it needs a second device that blocks the queue.
Rewardly: 3 if your till is one of four, otherwise 2. Papaya POS, Storyous, Portos and Dotykačka connect from the Advanced plan. Staff scan the card before the bill is closed, so the till knows whom to credit. With any other till, the scanner works on its own, which is a 2 for a busy counter. What each till shows differs, and the POS integrations compared goes through it.
4. Messages to customers
Test: send a message to yourself and ask who can get it, how much each one costs and how a customer sees it.
- 3: you can write, schedule and automate messages, and the price does not grow with each one.
- 2: messages work, with limits on who you can reach.
- 1: no messages, or a price per message you cannot predict.
Rewardly: 2. Push notifications go to the card in the customer's wallet. You can write a message and schedule it for a date up to a year ahead, and set a welcome message, a birthday message or a follow up that goes out after a number of days without a visit. Rewardly measures a 90% read rate on wallet messages (a company figure). The limits: push starts with the Advanced plan, not Basic, and the audience is everyone on a card, customers whose birthday is today, or one rule on a custom field. You cannot filter by visit history or tier.
5. Customer data export
Test: ask to see the export during the trial and open the file.
- 3: you export yourself, at any time, including after you leave.
- 2: you export yourself while you pay.
- 1: only on request to support, or as a paid extra.
Rewardly: 2. You export your customers to a CSV file from the dashboard, and so can analytics views. The limit: there is no export window after you stop paying, so export before you cancel.
6. Cost model
Test: price the tool at five times your size, then at two locations.
- 3: one flat price per location, with no charge per message, scan or customer.
- 2: a flat price plus one usage fee you can cap.
- 1: several fees that grow when the program works.
Rewardly: 3. Basic €29.90, Advanced €49.90 and Professional €79.90 per location per month, the same price for every location, with two months free if you pay yearly. Cards and customers are unlimited, and there is no setup fee and no fee per scan. Optional onboarding is €179.90 excluding VAT. The limits: there is no free plan, there is no volume discount at the moment and from five locations the price is custom. How much a digital loyalty program costs has the pricing models and a break even table.
7. Contract and cancelling
Test: ask for the term, the notice period, the renewal rule and the refund rule in writing.
- 3: month to month, you cancel with a click, and the terms are short and clear.
- 2: month to month, but with a rule you must plan around.
- 1: a fixed term that renews by itself.
Rewardly: 2. There is a 14 day trial. A payment card is required at signup and nothing is charged during the trial. After that, cancelling a monthly plan means the next payment does not happen. The limits: there are no refunds, not even on a yearly plan, a move to a cheaper plan starts at the next billing cycle, and customers' cards stay in their wallets for 30 days after you cancel. The questions to ask any vendor are in the 12 hidden cost questions.
8. Support
Test: write to support before you buy with a real question, and note how long the answer takes and whether it answers.
- 3: a person answers within a day and gives a written, specific reply.
- 2: you get an answer, but slowly or generally.
- 1: no way to reach anyone before you pay.
Rewardly: 2. Email support is part of every plan. We do not quote a guaranteed response time here. Ask us any question first, the way you would ask anyone else, and score the answer you get. Help with moving from another tool is possible if you contact support, but we do not promise it.
9. Languages
Test: open the dashboard, the join page and the staff tool in the language your team and customers use.
- 3: all three exist in the languages you need.
- 2: two of three, or the languages exist with gaps.
- 1: English only when your customers or staff are not.
Rewardly: 2. The dashboard, the join page and the scanner are in English, Slovak and Czech. The text on the card is whatever you write, so it can be in any language. The voucher shop is in English, Slovak and Czech and sells in euros. If your staff or customers need another language, score us 1 for that part.
10. Analytics
Test: ask what you see after 30 days, and whether you can see it for each location.
- 3: new members, returns, your best customers and each location, without a spreadsheet.
- 2: the basics, and the rest needs an export.
- 1: a total and nothing else.
Rewardly: 2. Analytics show new members, how often members return and your top customers, and they exist for each location. Basic analytics are in every plan and deeper ones sit in the higher plans, so check the plan table before you buy. The limit: it describes visits, not spending. The numbers to check every month shows which five matter.
Say a café scores three tools
Invented numbers. Say a café with one till scores three tools and has two must haves, staff speed and joining without an app.
Criterion | Tool A | Tool B | Tool C |
|---|---|---|---|
1 Joining | 3 | 3 | 2 |
2 Staff speed | 1 | 3 | 2 |
3 Till | 3 | 2 | 3 |
4 Messages | 3 | 2 | 3 |
5 Export | 3 | 2 | 3 |
6 Cost | 3 | 3 | 2 |
7 Contract | 3 | 2 | 2 |
8 Support | 3 | 2 | 2 |
9 Languages | 2 | 3 | 1 |
10 Analytics | 2 | 1 | 1 |
Total | 26 | 23 | 21 |
Tool A has the best total: 3+1+3+3+3+3+3+3+2+2 = 26. But it scores 1 on staff speed, a must have, so it is out. Tool B scores 23 and keeps both must haves at 2 or above. Tool C scores 21. The café picks B, then spends 20 minutes at its own till with B's staff tool before paying, because the score is a filter and the test is the decision.
What the score cannot tell you
A score does not choose your reward, train your staff or make customers join. Those decide more of the result than the software. Whether loyalty programs work for small businesses shows what the data can and cannot say, the card guide explains how a digital card works, and building your own loyalty app covers the custom route. If you want a ranked list for one trade instead of a method, see the 8 best loyalty apps for coffee shops compared.
Frequently asked questions
What features should loyalty software have for a small business?
At least these ten: joining without an app, a fast staff tool, a fit with your till, messages, an export of your data, a flat cost model, short contract terms, reachable support, your languages and simple analytics. Decide the two you cannot live without before you compare.
How much should loyalty software cost for one location?
It depends on what is included, so compare the price of the plan that has everything you need. With Rewardly it is €29.90, €49.90 or €79.90 a month per location (prices excluding VAT). A quick check of what the tool must earn is in the ROI calculator.
Do I need loyalty software that connects to my till?
No, but it removes a step. Without a connection staff scan the card and add the stamp or the amount themselves, which works at a calm counter. At a busy lunch counter, a connection is worth scoring higher. Check which tills each tool supports and on which plan.
Can I switch loyalty software later?
You can, but your customers' cards belong to the system that issued them, and your customer list is yours only if you can export it. Test the export during the trial, and ask what happens to the cards after you leave.
Is free loyalty software good enough?
It can be, for a start. Check what is limited: members, messages, export, support and the plan you move to when you grow. Rewardly has no free plan. It has a 14 day trial instead, which needs a payment card and charges nothing during the trial.
Score Rewardly yourself. Try it for €0
No upfront payment, 14 days free.


