Skip to content
Back to Blog
Loyalty Tips

When to send a customer reminder: timing by trade, from our data

When to send a customer reminder: 47 days for coffee shops, 32 for bakeries, 44 for restaurants, 45 for beauty. How to choose the days and what to say.

David Maroši
David Maroši8 min read
When to send a customer reminder: timing by trade, from our data

When should you send a customer a reminder? Around the day by which 3 in 4 returning customers are already back: 47 days for coffee shops, 32 for bakeries, 44 for restaurants and 45 for beauty, nails and fitness. Send it at the typical wait instead, and more than a third of the people you message were coming back anyway. The first reminder carries no offer, the second gives a reason, and only the third offers something small.

The figures come from Rewardly's analysis of more than 40,000 cards across 50+ businesses, in the study how soon members come back. This post is about the timing and the number of days you enter. How to build the follow up is in automated messages for customers and the message texts are in 12 win back messages.

What the data says about each trade

A visit is a card scanned on a given day. Some visits are never scanned, so real return rates are likely a little higher.

Trade

Typical wait

3 in 4 back within

Back within 90 days

Coffee shops

15 days

47 days

57.9%

Bakeries and sweets

11 days

32 days

55.2%

Restaurants and bistros

18 days

44 days

54.0%

Beauty, nails and fitness

27 days

45 days

51.6%

The typical wait is the median: half of the members who came back did so within that many days. The middle column is the point where 3 in 4 had done it. Between the two lies the stretch where a reminder is most likely to be wasted.

How to choose the number of days

In Rewardly the follow up starts after a visit and waits the number of days you enter. If the customer comes back before it runs out, nothing is sent. Pick that number with one of two rules:

  • For new members, use your trade's 3 in 4 day from the table: 47, 32, 44 or 45. By then most of the people who were going to return have done so, and the message goes to those who have not.
  • For regulars you most want to keep, use twice their usual gap. A customer who comes weekly is quiet after 14 days, and a 47 day wait would never catch them in time (the rule is in 12 win back messages).

One follow up has one number for every customer. If you must choose, choose by the customers you would hate to lose. Your own return rates are in Rewardly analytics; if your members clearly come back faster or slower than the table, move the number toward them.

What an earlier reminder costs

Say 100 new members join. The table gives the share who return within 90 days and the two points above. I treat the study's returners as the people who came back within 90 days (an approximation) and count how many recipients would have returned anyway:

Trade

Reminder at the 3 in 4 day

Reminder at the typical wait

Coffee

14 of 57 (a quarter)

29 of 71 (41%)

Bakery

14 of 59 (a quarter)

28 of 72 (38%)

Restaurant

14 of 60 (a quarter)

27 of 73 (37%)

Beauty

13 of 61 (a fifth)

26 of 74 (35%)

Each cell reads: recipients who would have come back anyway, out of everyone who gets the message. The coffee row is worked like this. 57.9% return, so about 58 of 100. By day 47, 3 in 4 of them are back, about 43. The reminder goes to the other 57, and about 14 of those (a quarter of the 58) would come back by themselves. At day 15, only half of the 58 are back, so the reminder goes to about 71 people and 29 of them were on their way anyway.

Messaging someone who was coming back costs little if the message is a reminder. It costs real money if it carries an offer.

What to say at each step

Rewardly lets you add a second and third step to the follow up. Each has its own wait, counted from the step before.

  1. Step 1: a reminder with no offer. One line, one piece of news. Wait for the number from the table. Example for a barbershop: "Your usual chair is free on Thursday afternoon."
  2. Step 2: a reason, 7 days later. Something that changed or that the customer can use: a new item, a free slot, a reward within reach. Example for a bakery: "The cinnamon rolls are back on Saturdays."
  3. Step 3: a small offer with a deadline, another 7 days later. Only the customers who ignored two messages get it, so the offer is not given to people who would have come. Example for a salon: "This month, a free hand mask with any treatment."

A week between steps is the spacing recommended in 12 win back messages, where you also find ready texts for every channel. For a trade like beauty, where the gap is long, there is nothing wrong with spacing step 2 and 3 two weeks apart.

So for a coffee shop the three waits are 47, 7 and 7 days: the messages go out around day 47, 54 and 61 after the last visit, if the customer has still not come back.

Worked example for each trade

All numbers are illustrative. Say 100 new members join each trade's card, one in ten of the recipients comes back because of the reminder, and the revenue is what they spend, not the profit.

Coffee shop

  1. Reminder at day 47 goes to about 57 members.
  2. 1 in 10 is about 6 visits.
  3. 6 × €5 = €30 of revenue, about €21 at a 70% margin.

Downside: you put a 20% discount in step 1. The 14 who were coming anyway use it: 14 × €1 = €14 given away, nearly half of the €30.

Bakery

  1. Reminder at day 32 goes to about 59 members.
  2. 1 in 10 is about 6 visits.
  3. 6 × €6 breakfast = €36 of revenue, about €25 at a 70% margin.

Downside: you set the wait at 11 days, the typical wait, by mistake. 72 get the message and 28 of them were coming anyway. If 7 visits follow, you cannot tell how many the message caused, so you over credit the automation and may stop looking for what really works.

Restaurant

  1. Reminder at day 44 goes to about 60 members.
  2. 1 in 10 is about 6 visits.
  3. 6 × €25 per visit = €150 of revenue, about €45 if 30% of the bill is left over.

Downside: only 1 in 20 responds, 3 visits, €75 of revenue and about €22 of margin. A restaurant has a lower margin per visit, so make step 2 a reason to book (a seasonal menu), not a discount.

Beauty, nails and fitness

  1. Reminder at day 45 goes to about 61 members.
  2. 1 in 10 is about 6 bookings.
  3. 6 × €40 = €240 of revenue, about €120 at a 50% margin.

Downside: all 6 want Thursday, but you have 3 free slots. 3 × €40 = €120 and three people are told no. Write the message with the open slots in it, and send step 1 only when the diary has room.

When to send scheduled messages

The follow up goes out a set number of days after the visit. For one off messages you choose the day and time. In Rewardly's data, 78% of visits by café members fall on weekdays, spread from opening until 17:00; for restaurants 34% fall between 12:00 and 14:00 and 30% after 17:00; for beauty and fitness Friday is the busiest day and 14:00 to 17:00 the busiest slot. Send before that time: a café before the morning coffee, a restaurant before lunch.

FAQ

How long after a customer's last visit should I send a reminder?

Around the day by which 3 in 4 returning customers are back: 47 days for coffee shops, 32 for bakeries, 44 for restaurants, 45 for beauty. If your regulars come weekly, use about twice their usual gap instead.

How many reminders should I send?

Three at most, a week apart. The first has no offer, the second gives a reason, and only the third has a small offer with a deadline.

Can I send the reminder only to customers who have been away 60 days?

No. Rewardly cannot filter by visit history. A follow up covers customers after a visit once it is switched on. For the ones already gone, write one message to all card holders.

Does the reminder work on every plan?

It needs the Advanced plan or above, at €49.90 per location per month (prices excluding VAT). The first 14 days are a trial: you add a payment card and nothing is charged.

What if my trade is not in the table?

Use the nearest one: a barbershop is close to beauty, a juice bar to a coffee shop. Then read your own return rates after 30 days and move the number.

Set your reminder. Try Rewardly for €0

No upfront payment, 14 days free.

Share this article

David Maroši

Written by

David Maroši

CEO, Rewardly

Continue Reading