Skip to content
Back to Blog
Loyalty Tips

How to win back lost customers: 12 messages you can send this week

How to win back lost customers: when a customer counts as lost, a three message sequence and 12 ready texts for push, SMS, email and the counter.

Roman Osadský
Roman Osadský9 min read
How to win back lost customers: 12 messages you can send this week

How do you win back lost customers? First decide when a customer counts as lost: when they have stayed away about twice as long as their usual gap between visits. Then send a short sequence: a gentle reminder with no discount, a concrete reason to come in a week later, and only at the end a small offer with a deadline. When they come back, welcome them in a way that makes them return again.

Winning back customers is not a blanket discount for everyone. Below you will find how to spot lost customers, how to build the sequence, 12 ready messages to copy, when to send them and what not to send.

Who counts as a lost customer

A lost customer is not simply someone who has not been in for a month. It depends on how often people normally visit you. Someone who has coffee with you three times a week is probably going elsewhere after three quiet weeks. A salon client who comes for a cut every six weeks is not lost after three.

A simple rule: a customer is lost when they have stayed away twice as long as usual for them. If they come once a week, get in touch after two weeks. If they come once a month, after two months.

Rewardly data on new loyalty members gives you a benchmark. Of the members who came back, 3 in 4 were back within 32 days at bakeries, 44 days at restaurants, 45 days at beauty, nail and fitness businesses and 47 days at coffee shops. The full picture is in the study 56% of new loyalty members come back within 90 days. Anyone who has not returned after that long is a candidate for a reminder.

How to find your lost customers

First you need to know who to contact. Look where you already have their details:

  1. Your loyalty card. In the Rewardly dashboard you see your card holders and their stamps or points. You can export the list as a CSV file.
  2. Your booking system. For a salon or a restaurant that takes bookings, this is the most precise source: you see who came in last and when.
  3. Your till. If your till keeps customer accounts, it shows who has stopped buying.
  4. Your team. Ask staff who they have not seen for a while. They remember regulars better than any report.

You may only message people who agreed to marketing messages. Push notifications from Rewardly skip customers without that consent automatically.

A three message sequence: reminder, reason, last offer

One message now and then is rarely enough. A short sequence works better, with each message adding a little more:

  1. A gentle reminder (once the customer passes their usual gap). No discount. Just "we are thinking of you" and one piece of news.
  2. A concrete reason (about a week later). A new dish, a seasonal drink, an open appointment slot, a reward the customer is close to.
  3. A last offer (another week later). A small perk with a clear deadline, for example a free pastry with any coffee until Sunday.

If the customer comes back after the first message, they do not get the other two. That way you only give a discount to the people nothing else convinced.

How to set it up in Rewardly

Rewardly has no ready made automation that messages customers based on when they last visited. You can send a message to all holders of a card, only to those whose birthday is today, or to a group you define with a custom field on your signup form. Selecting by last visit is not offered.

For future lost customers you build a follow up message yourself on the Advanced plan and above:

  1. A visit to your business starts it.
  2. The system waits for the next visit as long as you set (1 to 365 days).
  3. If the customer has not come back by that day, the message goes out. If they have, they get nothing.

You can add a second and third step with another wait in the same way. You write the texts yourself, and the customer's first name can be filled in automatically.

For customers who drifted away some time ago, write one message to all card holders. It has to please regulars and the people who have not been in for a while alike: something new, a seasonal offer, a new reward. You can write it in advance and schedule it for a specific day and time. More on how push notifications work is on the feature page.

12 win back messages to copy

Replace the names and offers with your own. Short messages read best, especially on a phone's lock screen.

Push notifications to the loyalty card

  1. Gentle reminder: "Good morning, {name}! We have a new Ethiopian coffee in. Stop by and try it."
  2. Something new: "Our new lunch menu starts Monday, and the soup of the day is back in its autumn version. See you soon."
  3. Close to a reward: "You are already collecting toward a free coffee on your card. Your next visit gets you closer."
  4. Last offer: "{name}, until Sunday a free pastry with any coffee. Just show your card at the till."
  5. Salon: "It has been a few weeks since your last cut. We have open slots this week, including Thursday afternoon."

SMS

You send SMS from your own phone or SMS service, only to customers who agreed to it.

  1. Salon: "Hi, it's Jana from Meadow Salon. We haven't seen you in a while. If you'd like an appointment, just reply and we'll find a time."
  2. Restaurant: "Corner Bistro: new menu this week with seasonal vegetables. Book a table at this number."

Email

  1. Subject: Something new for you. "Hi {name}, a few things have changed since your last visit: a new menu and longer opening hours on Fridays. We would love to see you. Your Corner Bistro team."
  2. Subject: A small treat until the end of the month. "Hi {name}, we miss you. Until the end of the month, a free dessert with your lunch is waiting for you. Just mention this email."

In person when they return

  1. "Hello, it's been a while! How are you?" (no reproach, with a smile)
  2. "We have new cakes since you were last here. Would you like a taste?"
  3. "Here's your stamp. Two more and your coffee is free."

More messages that bring customers back, for birthdays and name days, are in Birthday and name day messages that bring customers back.

When to send win back messages

  • When people decide. Morning coffee in the morning, lunch around eleven, salons in the afternoon when people plan their week. A lunch message at four in the afternoon is too late.
  • A week between messages. Shorter feels pushy, longer loses the thread.
  • Three messages at most in one sequence. Leave anyone who does not respond to the third in peace. They will still get your next news for all card holders.
  • Not on days you cannot cope. An offer for a Saturday when you are already full brings long waits and disappointment.

What to do when a customer comes back

Coming back is only the start. If the visit is the same as the last one and nothing links it to the next, the gap will open again.

  1. Welcome them naturally. Pleasure, not an interrogation. Why they stayed away is their business.
  2. Add the stamp or points and show the progress. They should leave feeling closer to the reward.
  3. Ask one question. "Is there anything you'd like to see here?" Sometimes you learn why they left.
  4. Give a reason for the next visit. The next salon appointment, a new dish next week.
  5. Keep the follow up message switched on, so you get in touch if they go quiet again.

How to turn a single visit into a regular habit is covered in How to get repeat customers.

What not to send

  • Guilt. "Have you forgotten us?" sounds like a reproach. Customers should not feel they owe you.
  • Exact day counts. "You haven't visited in 47 days" makes it sound as if you are watching them.
  • A big discount in the first message. Customers learn that staying away for a while earns a discount.
  • The same discount for everyone. Regulars would get it for no reason and you lose margin.
  • Messages without consent. Anyone who did not agree to marketing messages should not get them on any channel.
  • A general newsletter. Nobody finishes a long email about everything. One message, one thing.

FAQ

When is a customer considered lost?

When they have stayed away about twice as long as their usual gap between visits. In a café with daily guests that may be two to three weeks, in a salon two to three months. Adjust the rule to how your regulars actually visit.

Should I offer a lost customer a discount?

Only as a last resort. The first message should simply remind, the second should give a concrete reason. Send a small offer with a deadline only to those who did not respond, so you do not give a discount to people who would have come anyway.

How many lost customers can you win back?

Not all of them, and that is fine. Some have moved, changed jobs or found somewhere closer. Track how many customers came in after your messages and compare month by month.

Can I message only the customers who have not visited for a long time?

In Rewardly you can set up a follow up message that goes out when a customer has not come back within a number of days you choose after a visit. A one off message only to customers who have been away a long time is not offered, so for them write a message to all card holders that everyone will welcome.

Which channel works best to win back customers?

The one customers actually see and agreed to. A push notification on the card in their phone shows on the lock screen, SMS suits salons with a personal relationship, and email fits longer news. More on push messages is in A guide to push notifications for local businesses.

Bring your regulars back. Try Rewardly for €0

No upfront payment, 14 days free.

Share this article

Roman Osadský

Written by

Roman Osadský

Co-founder, Rewardly

Continue Reading