Loyalty program costs: the hidden fees and the real 12 month total
Loyalty program costs beyond the monthly fee: setup, printed cards, staff time, per message fees and exit costs. A 12 month total and 12 questions.

The monthly fee is the part of loyalty software you can see. The costs that surprise owners sit in five other places: a setup fee, a price that grows with messages or customers, a contract that renews itself, a customer export you can only ask for, and cards that stop working when you leave. This checklist has 12 questions for any vendor, with the answer to get in writing for each. In brackets you will find our own answer, so you can check whether we pass our own test.
For the prices themselves, the pricing models and a break even table, read how much a digital loyalty program costs. This article is about everything around the price.
How to use the list
Email the questions to every vendor on your shortlist before the trial ends and keep the replies. A good answer is short and specific. "It depends" and "contact sales" for a single café are answers too, just not good ones. The twelve questions fall into four groups: day one, how the bill grows, the contract and leaving.
Day one: what you pay before the first customer joins
1. Is there a setup or onboarding fee, and what does it cover? A fee is fair when real work sits behind it, such as designing the card, connecting the till or training staff. Ask what you get for it and whether it comes back every time you add a location. (Rewardly: no setup fee. Optional onboarding is €179.90 excluding VAT, only if you want help. Launching a card takes about 2 minutes.)
2. What does the trial cost, and what happens on the last day? Ask whether a payment card is needed, who charges you after the trial and how to stop it. (Rewardly: a 14 day trial. You add a payment card at signup, nothing is charged during the trial and the first payment is taken automatically after it. If you cancel, the next payment does not happen.)
3. Which plan do I need for what I saw in the demo? Features move between plans: the till connection, messages to customers, selling vouchers. Ask for the cheapest plan that does everything the demo showed, and price that one. (Rewardly: Basic has the cards, Apple Wallet and Google Wallet, the staff scanner and basic analytics. Push notifications and the till connections start with Advanced. Selling gift cards and vouchers online needs Professional.)
How the bill grows
4. What do you count? Locations, cards, customers, messages, staff users and scans are all units a bill can grow by. Every one of them grows when the program works, so ask for the price at five times your size, not at today's. (Rewardly: the price is per location per month. Cards and customers are unlimited on every plan and there is no charge per scan.)
5. Do messages to customers cost extra? This is the question where cheap offers turn expensive, and the example further down shows how. (Rewardly: push notifications are part of the Advanced and Professional price, with no charge per message.)
6. What does the second location cost? Ask whether it costs the same as the first, less or more, and where custom pricing starts. (Rewardly: every location pays the same plan price. Three locations on Advanced are 3 × €49.90 = €149.70 a month. There is no volume discount at the moment. From five locations the price is custom.) If you run several locations, 5 decisions to make early covers the rest.
7. Can the price change during the term, and when can I change plan? Ask how much notice you get before a price rise and whether moving to a cheaper plan takes effect at once or at the next billing date. (Rewardly: moving down a plan takes effect at the next billing cycle.)
The contract: how long you are bound
8. What are the minimum term, the notice period and the renewal rule? A 12 month term that renews by itself, with a notice period you must send in writing, is the usual way a tool you wanted to drop costs another year. Say a vendor charges €40 a month on a 12 month term that ends on 31 December. The contract renews unless you give written notice 60 days before the end, which means by 1 November. If you miss that date by a day, you owe another 12 × €40 = €480 for something you had already decided to stop using. (Rewardly: on a monthly plan, cancelling means the next payment does not happen. A yearly plan is paid for 10 months instead of 12.)
9. If it does not work, do I get money back? This matters most on yearly prepayment. (Rewardly: there are no refunds, not even on a yearly plan. That is why the trial comes first, and why we suggest choosing the yearly plan only after it.)
Leaving: your data and your customers' cards
10. Can I export my customer list, in which format and until when? The export is the one thing you take with you, so look at it before you pay. A red flag is an export that exists only by request to support or as a paid extra. (Rewardly: you can export your customers to a CSV file while your plan is paid. There is no export window after you stop paying, so export before you cancel.)
11. What do my customers' cards do after I leave? Ask what a customer sees on the day you cancel and on day 31. Do the cards stop at once, show an error or keep working for a while? (Rewardly: cards stay available in customers' wallets for 30 days after you cancel.)
12. Who owns the data, and where is it stored? Ask who may use your customers' details, where the servers are and whether a data processing agreement is available. (Rewardly: the data is hosted in the EU, it is yours and is never sold or shared, and a data processing agreement is available.)
A cheap start that grows with your messages
Invented numbers, so replace them with the quotes you hold. Say a bakery has 800 members and receives this offer: €29 a month, a €250 setup fee and €0.04 for every message sent. Compare it with a flat plan at €49.90 a month, the price of Advanced (prices excluding VAT).
Campaigns a month | Messages | Offer: monthly bill | Offer: year one with setup | Flat plan: year one |
|---|---|---|---|---|
0 | 0 | €29 | €598 | €598.80 |
2 | 1,600 | €93 | €1,366 | €598.80 |
4 | 3,200 | €157 | €2,134 | €598.80 |
The arithmetic for two campaigns: 800 members × 2 campaigns = 1,600 messages, and 1,600 × €0.04 = €64. Add the €29 fee and the monthly bill is €93. Over a year that is 12 × €93 = €1,116, plus the €250 setup fee = €1,366. A flat plan is €49.90 × 12 = €598.80 whatever you send.
The offer only matches the flat plan if you never message your customers, which is the thing a loyalty card is for. If you accept a price per message, ask for a monthly cap on the bill before you start. The contract date from question 8 deserves the same care: put the end date and the notice date in your calendar the day you sign, with a reminder two weeks before.
The total cost of a loyalty system, beyond the plan price
A loyalty system costs more than its subscription. Add up five things before you compare vendors:
- Setup and onboarding. Ask what is charged once and what it covers. At Rewardly there is no setup fee, and optional onboarding is €179.90 excluding VAT, only if you want help.
- Printed cards or digital. A paper or plastic card has to be printed, reprinted when stock runs out and replaced when a guest loses it, and it tells you nothing about who holds it. A digital card sits in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet and costs nothing to print or replace. Get a quote for printing before you compare.
- Staff time. Counting stamps, searching for a lost card and keying in amounts all happen at the till. A scanner takes a few seconds, and with a POS connection nothing is typed.
- POS integration. The till connection starts with Advanced, which is €20 more per location a month than Basic (€49.90 against €29.90), or €240 a year. Check whether your POS vendor charges anything on its side.
- Messages. Per message pricing is covered above. With Rewardly, push notifications are included in Advanced and Professional.
Total cost of ownership over 12 months: a worked example
The numbers are assumptions for illustration, not data from real businesses. Assumptions: one café with 600 members. On paper, 1,200 cards are printed and replaced in a year at €0.10 each. Staff time is valued at €10 an hour: 2 hours a month with paper (counting stamps, lost cards, tallying), 30 minutes a month with the Basic scanner and 15 minutes a month with Advanced and a POS connection. Prices excluding VAT, monthly billing.
Cost over 12 months | Paper cards | Rewardly Basic | Rewardly Advanced with POS |
|---|---|---|---|
Subscription | €0 | €358.80 | €598.80 |
Optional onboarding | €0 | €0 | €179.90 |
Printing and replacing cards | €120 | €0 | €0 |
Staff time | €240 | €60 | €30 |
Total, year one | €360 | €418.80 | €808.70 |
Total, year two | €360 | €418.80 | €628.80 |
The arithmetic for Advanced in year one: €49.90 × 12 = €598.80, plus €179.90 onboarding, plus 3 hours × €10 = €30, which is €808.70. Without onboarding, year two is €628.80. Paper is the cheapest line on the invoice, and it is also the only option with no customer list, no reminders and no numbers. In this example, Basic costs €58.80 more than paper over a year, and Advanced costs €268.80 more from year two, which pays for the till connection and push notifications. Replace every figure with your own quotes.
Looking for the price list rather than the full cost? The plan prices, the pricing models and the break even table are in how much a digital loyalty program costs.
Before you pay: four checks in one afternoon
- Get the terms in writing. Find five clauses: the term, the renewal, the notice period, how a price change is announced and what happens to your data when you leave.
- Open the export. If the vendor lets you export during the trial, do it on day one and open the file. If it does not let you, that is an answer to question 10.
- Price year one and year two separately. Year one carries the setup fee and any prepayment, year two shows the running cost. The three line version is in the ROI calculator, which also subtracts the cost of rewards.
- Put two vendors side by side. One row per question, one column per vendor. The cheaper offer is the one with the lower year two total and the clearer exit.
Red flags that are worth a second look: a price "on request" for one location, "unlimited" with a footnote, an export only through support, a notice period in months, and an answer that changes between the call and the contract.
Where Rewardly is strict
Four answers above are not generous, and you should weigh them. A payment card is needed for the trial. There are no refunds, even on a yearly plan. You can export customers only while the plan is paid. Cards stay in wallets for 30 days after you cancel. We would rather you read them here than find out later. If you are choosing between a ready made tool and a custom built app, building a loyalty app for your café or restaurant lists the questions to ask an agency, and what a café loyalty program costs per month puts one location in numbers.
Frequently asked questions
Are there hidden fees in loyalty programs?
The usual ones are a setup or onboarding fee, a price per message or per customer, a charge for each extra location, a paid export and a renewal you did not mean to accept. Ask the 12 questions above and get the answers in writing.
Can I cancel a loyalty program at any time?
It depends on the term. On a monthly plan you can usually stop whenever you like, but on a fixed term you may owe the whole period. With Rewardly, cancelling a monthly plan means the next payment does not happen, and a yearly plan is not refunded.
What happens to my customers' cards if I cancel?
That is up to the vendor, so ask what a customer sees on the day you cancel and 30 days later. With Rewardly, the cards stay available in the customers' wallets for 30 days after you cancel.
Do loyalty programs charge per message?
Some do, and a price per message grows with the number of members and campaigns. Ask for the bill at your expected volume. With Rewardly, push notifications are included in Advanced and Professional, with no charge per message.
Can I take my customer data with me?
Ask for the format, and whether the export works after you stop paying. Rewardly exports customers to CSV while the plan is paid, so do it before you cancel.
Check the answers on a real account. Try Rewardly for €0
No upfront payment, 14 days free.


