Skip to content
Back to Blog
Loyalty Tips

Customer acquisition vs retention cost: what a new customer really costs you

Customer acquisition vs retention cost: both formulas, a worked café example, when new customers matter more, how to split a budget and what to track monthly.

Roman Osadský
Roman Osadský9 min read
Customer acquisition vs retention cost: what a new customer really costs you

What costs more, acquiring a new customer or keeping one? Customer acquisition cost is your marketing and promotion spend divided by the number of new customers. Retention cost is what you spend to bring existing customers back divided by the number who returned.

For a local business, keeping a regular usually costs several times less, but you still need new customers when you are starting out or when people naturally move on.

Below are both formulas, a worked café example, the situations where acquisition matters more, a simple way to split your budget and five numbers to write down once a month.

What is customer acquisition cost?

Customer acquisition cost (CAC) is how much you spend, on average, to get one person through your door for the first time.

Customer acquisition cost = (marketing spend + promotion costs) ÷ number of new customers

Count everything you do to bring in people who have never visited:

  1. Paid ads: Instagram, Facebook, Google, the local paper.
  2. Print: flyers, posters, the board outside.
  3. Offers for newcomers: an opening discount, tastings, a free first coffee. Count what the product costs you, not its menu price.
  4. Partnerships: a fee for a local influencer, a stall at a neighbourhood event.

Counting new customers is the hard part. It helps if staff ask "First time here?" at the till, if each offer has its own code, or if you track how many new people join your loyalty card each month.

What does it cost to keep an existing customer?

Customer retention cost is how much you spend to get someone who has already been in to come back again.

Customer retention cost = spend on bringing regulars back ÷ number of returning customers

This includes:

  • Loyalty rewards at cost: a free coffee does not cost you its menu price, it costs the beans, milk and cup.
  • Small treats: a birthday cake slice, a taste of a new item for regulars.
  • Messages to regulars and the tool you send them with.
  • Your loyalty program, if you pay for it monthly.

A returning customer is someone who has visited before and came again this month. A loyalty card shows you this directly; without one you can only guess.

Worked example: a café with round numbers

Example: a café spends €400 a month on Instagram ads, €150 on flyers and €200 on product for a "second coffee free for newcomers" offer. That is €750. Sixty people visit for the first time. Customer acquisition cost is 750 ÷ 60 = €12.50.

>

In the same month 340 regulars come back. The café gives away 60 free coffees from its loyalty card (€0.90 each at cost, €54 in total), 15 birthday cookies (€1 each, €15) and pays €49.90 for its loyalty program. That is about €119. Customer retention cost is 119 ÷ 340 = €0.35.

>

These are illustrative numbers, not data from a real business.

The calculation has one weak spot: not all 340 regulars came back because of the reward, many would have come anyway. If only a third of them returned thanks to the card and the treats, retention costs 119 ÷ 113, about €1.05 per customer. That is still roughly twelve times less than acquiring a new one.

When does a new customer pay for themselves?

The second number that matters is how many visits a new customer needs before they pay back what you spent to get them.

Visits to pay back = customer acquisition cost ÷ gross margin per visit

If a guest spends €5 on average before tax and ingredients cost €2, your margin per visit is €3. At €12.50 to acquire, that is 12.50 ÷ 3, just over four visits. They pay for themselves on the fifth. A customer who comes once has cost you money. You only start earning when they come back. That is why acquisition and retention cannot be separated: advertising only pays if you can turn a first visit into a second one.

Why retention usually wins

A 2014 Harvard Business Review article says that, depending on which study you believe and what industry you are in, acquiring a new customer is five to 25 times more expensive than retaining an existing one. That is not a precise figure for a café or salon, but the direction holds for simple reasons:

  1. Regulars already know you. You do not have to tell them where you are or what you sell, only give them a reason to come sooner.
  2. A reward costs you its cost price. Advertising is paid in full whether anyone comes or not.
  3. Regulars make most of your visits. In Rewardly data, the top 20% of loyalty members made 65% of all member visits in a typical business, as the study Your top 20% of members bring two thirds of your visits shows.
  4. They recommend you and write reviews. A happy regular is the cheapest advertising you have.
  5. They come when it is quiet. You can invite them on a slow day with a message; an ad cannot send a stranger in at a specific hour.

Rewardly clients report 30% more repeat visits. How quickly you can tell who will stay is covered in Members who return in their first month are 2.7 times as likely to stay a year.

When does acquisition matter more?

Retention is not always first. Put more money into new customers when:

  • You are just starting. With no regulars there is nobody to keep. The first months are about people finding you at all.
  • Your area has high churn: tourists, students, offices moving out, a spot by a station. Some customers leave however well you treat them.
  • You have spare capacity. If your salon is booked three weeks ahead, more newcomers will not help. If your lunches are half empty, they will.
  • You have lost customers, after a move or when someone new opened nearby.
  • You are launching a new service or location your regulars do not need.

Even then, one rule holds: capture every new person on their first visit. If they add your loyalty card to their phone at the till, you can invite them back later without paying for another ad. Adding a digital loyalty card to Apple Wallet or Google Wallet takes about 10 seconds and needs no app.

How to split your budget between new and existing customers

There is no single right split. A sensible starting point depends on where you are:

  1. New business (first six months): most of the money on getting known, a smaller share on the card and small treats so the first guests come back.
  2. Established business with full peaks: most of it on regulars and on your slow hours, on new customers only enough to replace the ones who naturally move on.
  3. Established business losing customers: find out why first. If people do not come back, advertising will not fill the hole, it will only make it bigger.

Move money based on numbers, not gut feeling. If your acquisition cost is high and newcomers do not return, cut ads and spend on the first impression and a reason to come back. To see what a loyalty program earns you after its costs, use the free loyalty program ROI calculator.

What to measure every month

A few minutes once a month and one notebook or spreadsheet are enough:

  1. Number of new customers. New loyalty members are the best measure you have.
  2. Customer acquisition cost, using the formula above.
  3. Number of returning customers and their share of all visits.
  4. Customer retention cost, using the second formula.
  5. How many newcomers came back at least once within a month of their first visit. This tells you whether the ads paid off.

More numbers you can read straight from a loyalty program are in 5 loyalty program numbers to check every month.

FAQ

Is it really cheaper to keep a customer than to get a new one?

Usually, yes. Harvard Business Review puts acquiring a new customer at five to 25 times the cost of keeping one, depending on the study and the industry. In a small business you can see it in your own numbers: a loyalty reward costs you its cost price, an ad costs its full price.

How do I calculate customer acquisition cost?

Add up everything you spent in a month on ads and offers for newcomers, then divide by the number of people who visited for the first time. Count offers at the cost of the product. Count new customers by new loyalty members, an offer code or a question at the till.

How much should a new customer cost a café or salon?

As much as they pay back. Divide your acquisition cost by your margin per visit to get the number of visits it takes a customer to pay for themselves. If that is more visits than a typical newcomer makes, your ads cost more than they bring.

Should I stop advertising and focus only on regulars?

No. Some regulars always leave, move away or change jobs, and someone has to replace them. Keep advertising at a level you can turn into return visits, and capture new customers on their very first visit.

How do I know whether a new customer came back?

Without records you can only guess, based on whether staff recognise them. With a loyalty card you see it directly: when the customer joined and when they came again. That is why it pays to offer the card on the first payment.

Turn new customers into regulars. Try Rewardly for €0

No upfront payment, 14 days free.

Share this article

Roman Osadský

Written by

Roman Osadský

Co-founder, Rewardly

Continue Reading