Skip to content
Back to Blog
Loyalty Tips

Loyalty app vs wallet card: decision table and 3 year cost

Loyalty app vs wallet card: a decision table and a 3 year cost comparison with illustrative numbers you replace with your own quote, café example included.

Roman Osadský
Roman Osadský6 min read
Loyalty app vs wallet card: decision table and 3 year cost

For a loyalty program on its own, a wallet card in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet is the cheaper and quicker choice: from €29.90 a month per location with Rewardly, live in 2 minutes, no store review (prices excluding VAT). An own app is the better choice only when loyalty is one feature next to ordering, bookings or content. This post gives you a table to decide and a 3 year cost comparison with illustrative numbers that you replace with your agency's quote.

Why customers join a card more easily than an app is covered in loyalty without an app: when it works and when an app is better. What a quote has to contain, and 10 questions to ask before you sign, are in building a loyalty app: costs and 10 questions.

The decision table


Own app

Wallet card with Rewardly

Customer joins by

Store, download, account, notification question: up to nine steps

QR code, short form, tap to add: three steps, about 10 seconds

Customer needs

An iPhone or Android phone and a download

Apple Wallet or Google Wallet, no fallback without one

Launch

A project: ask the agency for a delivery date in writing

2 minutes, no store review

Staff

A staff tool must be in the quote

Scanner in the browser on a phone or tablet, or your till from Advanced

Messages

Notifications inside the app, after the customer allows them

Messages on the card to customers who agreed to marketing, from Advanced

Ordering, bookings, menu, games

Yes, if the quote includes them

No

Upkeep

A developer for Apple and Google requirements, plus a server

The platform's job, app store rules do not apply to a wallet card

Data

Ask who owns the database and the code

Stored in the EU, customers export to CSV

Price

A quote: build plus upkeep

€29.90, €49.90 or €79.90 per location per month

Read down the "Ordering, bookings, menu, games" row first. If you need none of them, the rest of the table points to the card.

The 3 year cost, as a hypothetical

Say a café with one location gets a quote for its own app. These numbers are made up for the arithmetic, not market prices. Rewardly does not publish an average build price because quotes vary too much for one to help. Replace each line with the figures in your quote.

Own app, 3 years:

  1. Build: €6,000.
  2. Maintenance: 3 × €1,200 = €3,600.
  3. Server: 36 months × €30 = €1,080.
  4. Apple Developer Program and Google Play: 3 × $99 + $25 = $322, about €300.
  5. Total: €6,000 + €3,600 + €1,080 + €300 = €10,980.

Wallet card on Advanced, 3 years (push and POS integration need Advanced):

  1. Monthly billing: 36 × €49.90 = €1,796.40.
  2. Yearly billing, 2 months free: 3 × 10 × €49.90 = €1,497.00.

In this example the app costs more than €9,000 extra over 3 years. Per month that is €10,980 ÷ 36 = €305 for the app against €49.90 for the card.

Now turn it into visits. Say the café's average ticket is €6 and it keeps 70%, so one extra visit is worth €4.20 in margin:

  1. App: €305 ÷ €4.20 = 72.6, so 73 extra visits a month to cover its cost. On revenue it is €305 ÷ €6 = 51 visits.
  2. Card: €49.90 ÷ €4.20 = 11.9, so 12 extra visits a month. On revenue, 9 visits.

Two things can change the picture. First, quotes often leave out the admin area and the staff tool, and without them the app does not work (the quote checklist explains why), so check your quote line by line. Second, if the app is being built anyway for ordering, loyalty is a feature, not the reason, and you only price that feature. You can also keep both: the app for ordering and the card for customers who do not want to download anything.

A chain changes it too. An app serves every location with one build, while a wallet plan is charged per location, flat. At four locations, the most you can buy in self serve, the same example gives 4 × €1,796.40 = €7,185.60 on monthly billing and 4 × €1,497 = €5,988 on yearly billing, still below €10,980. From five locations the price is custom, so ask us for a quote and read loyalty for multiple locations.

For the cost of a plan against a café's takings, see how much a digital loyalty program costs. To test your own ticket and margin, use the free ROI calculator.

How to decide in three questions

  1. Do you need ordering, bookings, a menu or games on the phone? If yes, price the app for those and run the loyalty card next to it. If no, take the card.
  2. Are customers fine with Apple Wallet or Google Wallet? A phone with neither cannot save the card. Ask your staff which phones your regulars carry.
  3. Can you wait for a build and pay for its upkeep for years? If not, start with a card. A trial costs you 14 days, a build costs you the whole quote.

When the answer is a card, the next step is how to launch a loyalty card without an app, in order, from the reward to the first 100 members.

FAQ

Can I have my own app and a wallet card?

Yes. The app can handle ordering, and the wallet card can run the loyalty program for customers who do not want to download an app.

How much does it cost to build a loyalty app?

Quotes vary too much for an average to help. Use the 3 year formula above with your own quote, and the 10 questions in the app development guide to compare quotes line by line.

Does a wallet card work on iPhone and Android?

Yes. iPhone saves it to Apple Wallet and Android to Google Wallet. A phone with neither cannot save it.

What happens to my customer data if I switch provider?

With Rewardly you can export your customers as a CSV file, and the data is stored in the EU. With an own app, get a written answer on who owns the database and the code before you sign.

Launch your loyalty card. Try Rewardly for €0

No upfront payment, 14 days free.

Share this article

Roman Osadský

Written by

Roman Osadský

Co-founder, Rewardly

Continue Reading