Skip to content
Back to Blog
Loyalty Tips

Loyalty program ROI calculator: what a card earns you after costs

Work out for free what a loyalty card adds each month after product cost, rewards and the program price. A few questions, and you can change every number.

Roman Osadský
Roman Osadský5 min read
Loyalty program ROI calculator: what a card earns you after costs

A loyalty card costs money. You pay for the program, you give rewards away, and every free coffee has a product cost. So the real question is not whether customers will come back, but whether anything is left once everything is paid for. That is why we built a free loyalty program ROI calculator. Answer a few short questions and you get an estimate for your own business, with every assumption in plain view.

What the calculator asks

First you pick your type of business: café, restaurant, bakery or another local business. The calculator sets its starting numbers from that. Then come eleven questions in three parts:

  • Your business: its name, how many customers come in on a typical day, how many days a week you are open, the average spend and how many locations you have.
  • Your customers: how you bring customers back today, how many of 10 new customers return within a month, and how often a typical regular comes in.
  • Your card: how much of every €10 a customer spends is product cost, what the reward costs on your menu, and whether your team will offer the card at the counter.

For most questions one tap on a suggested value is enough. If you do not know a number, choose "I don't know" and the calculator uses a typical value for your type of business.

The ROI calculator question "How do you bring customers back today?" with four options: nothing formal, paper stamp cards, discounts for regulars, and a loyalty app or POS points.

The question that matters most is how you bring customers back today. If you have nothing formal, there is the most room to improve. If you already run a loyalty app or POS points, you get only a small lift, mostly because a card in the phone's wallet does not need an app download.

What you get

At the end you see one main number: how much the card can add every month after all costs. Below it are the likely range and a rough total for the year. Next to it is a breakdown in four lines:

  1. How many extra customers come in per day, and how many of 10 new customers return today and with the card.
  2. Extra sales per month, that is extra visits times the average spend.
  3. Costs per month: products, rewards and the Rewardly plan.
  4. What you keep.
ROI calculator result for the invented Aurora Café: the main figure added every month after costs, the breakdown of sales and costs, and a suggested stamp card on a phone.

The numbers in the image are only an example with made up answers, not the result of a real business. Yours will be different.

The calculator also suggests the card itself: the number of stamps, the reward and how soon a typical regular earns it. It picks the number of stamps so that a regular fills the card in about six weeks. This is based on a field study in a café, where customers bought coffee more often the closer they got to a free one (Kivetz, Urminsky and Zheng, Journal of Marketing Research, 2006).

Why the number is lower than elsewhere

Many calculators show sales and say nothing about costs. This one does the opposite:

  • It subtracts costs. From the extra sales it takes off the cost of what you sell, the cost of rewards and the price of the Advanced plan. It does not subtract rent or wages, because they do not change when a regular comes in once more.
  • It counts rewards at product cost. A free coffee does not cost you the menu price, only the ingredients.
  • It does not treat every extra visit as new. Some customers would have come anyway. The low end of the range therefore counts only 65 % of the extra visits as new.
  • It leaves out what cannot be estimated. New customers from referrals, push campaigns and bigger orders from members do happen, but they are not in the forecast.

If your numbers show no extra profit, the calculator shows no amount at all. It tells you the card is mainly about keeping the regulars you already have, and what would change the result.

You can change every number

Below the result, click "Show and change the numbers". You see every input of the calculation, each with a label saying whether it is your number or our assumption. You can overwrite an assumption, and with "Use ours" you can go back to it at any time. The result updates straight away.

The ROI calculator numbers opened up: customers per day, average spend, locations, return rate, visits per regular, days open, gross margin, regulars who join, stamps per reward and reward price, each labelled your number or our assumption.

Two numbers are worth playing with:

  • Regulars who join. This depends mostly on whether your staff offer the card to everyone. If they do, the lift grows.
  • Customers who come back within a month. You know your regulars better than any average. If the starting value looks high or low, overwrite it.

You can also show the amounts in USD, CZK, PLN or HUF.

How to answer so the estimate fits

  • Count customers as people, not orders. A family at one table is one bill but several people.
  • For product cost, count only ingredients and goods, not rent or wages.
  • If you have several locations, enter customers per day for one location. The calculator multiplies it for you.
  • Be honest about your team. A card nobody offers does not spread.

The whole thing takes a few minutes, needs no account or email, and costs nothing.

What next

The calculator is an estimate, not a promise. It is based on your answers, not on data from your business. You will only see the real numbers once the card is running.

The "Create this card free" button opens Rewardly with the suggested number of stamps. Customers add the card to Apple Wallet or Google Wallet from a QR code at the counter in about 10 seconds, without downloading an app, and staff add stamps in the Rewardly app on a phone. If you want to think the number of stamps through yourself first, read How many stamps to put on a loyalty card. And if you would rather start with a paper card, try our free loyalty card maker.

Test the estimate in practice. Try Rewardly for €0

No upfront payment, set up in 2 minutes.

Share this article

Roman Osadský

Written by

Roman Osadský

Co-founder, Rewardly

Continue Reading