Skip to content
Back to Blog
Loyalty Tips

Loyalty reward ideas: what to give, what it costs and what it is worth

Loyalty reward ideas with the numbers: what to give, what each reward costs against its menu price, examples for cafés and shops and a check before launch.

Roman Osadský
Roman Osadský9 min read
Loyalty reward ideas: what to give, what it costs and what it is worth

The best loyalty rewards cost you little and are worth much more at your menu price: a dessert, a drink, an add on treatment, a small product to take home. A simple test is the value ratio, the menu price of the reward divided by what it costs you. In the table below, a free coffee scores 4.9, a dessert 3.4 and a sample size product 3.8. Money off the next bill always scores 1.0, because every euro you give away is a euro. Aim for a ratio of 3 or more, as a rule of thumb and not a benchmark, and read the rest of this guide for ideas by trade, rewards that cost almost nothing and a check to run before you launch.

All prices and costs are illustrative, so replace them with yours. This guide is about what the reward is. Which card pays it out is in loyalty program ideas for cafés and restaurants, and how many stamps or points earn it is in how many stamps on a loyalty card.

Two numbers for every reward

  • What it is worth to the customer. The price they would pay for it on your menu or price list.
  • What it costs you. Ingredients, packaging and anything you pay to hand it over. Add staff minutes only if that time would otherwise have been sold: a haircut slot, a chair, a table.

Divide the first by the second and you have the value ratio. A high ratio means the customer feels well rewarded while you give up little. It says nothing about how often the reward is claimed, so check the cost against what members spend as well.

The reward cost table

Trade

Reward

Menu price

Cost to you

Value ratio

Café

Free coffee

€3.20

€0.65

4.9

Café

Pastry with the next drink

€2.80

€0.90

3.1

Bakery

Free croissant

€1.90

€0.55

3.5

Restaurant

Dessert

€6.50

€1.90

3.4

Restaurant

Lemonade

€3.50

€0.50

7.0

Salon

Scalp massage, 10 minutes

€15.00

€7.50

2.0

Barbershop

Mini styling wax

€9.00

€2.80

3.2

Shop

Sample size product

€6.00

€1.60

3.8

Shop

Free gift wrapping

€3.00

€0.40

7.5

Shop

Free delivery

€4.90

€3.80

1.3

Any trade

€5 off the next bill

€5.00

€5.00

1.0

How the costs were built: the scalp massage is €1.50 of product plus 10 minutes of a stylist's time valued at €6. The rest are the cost of making or buying the item. Your supplier invoices and recipe costs give you the real figures.

What 100 rewards cost: say your card hands out 100 rewards in a month.

  1. 100 free coffees: 100 × €0.65 = €65 in cost, €320 of menu value for the customers.
  2. 100 times €5 off: 100 × €5 = €500.
  3. €500 ÷ €65 = 7.7, so the discount costs you 7.7 times more per reward.

A discount can still be the right choice, because customers choose what to spend it on. Then the card has to bring enough extra visits to pay for each €5.

Reward ideas by trade

Café: the drink and something to go with it

A free coffee has the best ratio of the café rewards, since the milk and beans cost far less than the menu price. A pastry with the next drink scores lower at 3.1 but does something else: it lifts the bill of a customer who is already at the till. With a connected till on the Advanced plan, the reward can free a chosen product on the bill, so staff do not have to remember what to waive. The loyalty setup for coffee shops shows the card.

Bakery: a small thing they take home

A croissant or a roll costs well under a euro and lands as a treat. Give it with the customer's next purchase, handed over with their bread, so the reward is a visit, not a trip for one pastry. Bakery members who return at all typically do so after 11 days (how soon loyalty members come back by industry), so a small reward claimed at the next visit fits the rhythm.

Restaurant: dessert, a soft drink or a starter

Dessert and a soft drink are the restaurant rewards with the lowest cost against their menu price. A lemonade scores 7.0 and a dessert 3.4. A main course sold at €14 that costs €5.20 to make scores 2.7, so keep it for the top of a points card. If you use a points card, the dessert can sit at one points price and a main course at a higher one. How to set up a cashback card in a restaurant covers the money back alternative.

Salon: an add on, never a free service

A scalp massage, a brow shape or a conditioning treatment costs you minutes and a little product. A free colour or cut costs the whole appointment if that slot would have been sold, which is a ratio of 1.0 at best. The scalp massage in the table scores 2.0 only because a stylist's time is counted. If the chair would be empty anyway, the cost falls to €1.50 and the ratio to 10.

Barbershop: a product, a trim or a priority slot

A mini styling wax scores 3.2 and lets the customer try something you also sell. A beard trim costs chair time. Priority booking costs nothing but a diary habit, so it suits your best regulars. More on the rhythm of rewards in barbershop loyalty program.

Shop: samples and wrapping, not delivery

A sample size product scores 3.8 and brings the customer back to try the full size. Free gift wrapping costs a bit of paper and a minute and feels like a service. Free delivery looks generous but costs nearly what it is worth, a ratio of 1.3, so it is a weak reward unless delivery is already part of your price. Loyalty for retail shows a card for shops.

Rewards that cost almost nothing

  • Recognition. A VIP card has 1 to 5 tiers that customers reach on their own after a number of visits or an amount spent, each with its own percentage discount. Give each tier a name and one thing that is not money: the first taste of a new dish, a seat held, the first pick of Saturday slots. In Rewardly's data of 41,187 members of 60 businesses, the top 20% made 65% of member visits (your top 20% of members). They come back without being asked, so being recognised often matters more than a bigger discount. More on VIP cards.
  • A birthday gift. On the Advanced plan and above, the birthday message goes out on the birthday morning and needs the date of birth as an optional field in the sign up form. The gift itself, a pastry or a drink, is something staff hand over. Birthday and name day messages has the texts.
  • A surprise at the counter. An extra cookie when a member's card is full costs a few cents and nobody planned it, so it does not teach customers to wait for it. Staff do this by choice, with no rule behind it.

Rewards that work less well

  • Cash off the next bill. Value ratio 1.0 by definition. Use it for a quiet slot you need to fill, with an end date.
  • A free service that takes a full slot. A free haircut or colour costs the slot, which is why an add on is better.
  • A big reward very far away. A reward the customer sees coming within weeks beats a bigger one a year away. The sum is in how many stamps on a loyalty card.
  • Something dull. A digital card ends lost paper cards and gives you visit counts. It will not make a weak reward interesting.

Test a reward before you launch it

  1. Price it. Menu price, cost, ratio. Below 2, look for a cheaper version of the same idea.
  2. Ask ten regulars. "Would you rather have the free dessert or €5 off?" Count the answers at the till for a week. It is a small test, not a study.
  3. Check the handover. The reward must take staff seconds. When the last stamp goes on, the reward is ready at once, and staff confirm it in the scanner in two taps, or the connected till takes it off the bill. The scanner runs in the browser on a phone or tablet, nothing to install.
  4. Check the cost against spend. Divide what the reward costs you by what a member spends to earn it. The sum is in the stamps article above.
  5. Count after 30 days. Keep a tally of rewards handed over and look at your second visit rate. 5 loyalty program numbers to check every month lists the others.

To see the reward on a card before you create it, design it in the free loyalty card maker. Rewardly clients report 30% more repeat visits, but your own second visit rate is the number to manage.

FAQ

What are good loyalty rewards for a small business?

A low cost item that customers value at your menu price: a free coffee, a dessert, an add on treatment, a sample size product. A value ratio of 3 or more is a good aim.

How do I reward customers without giving away margin?

Reward with things that cost you little, not with money off. A free coffee costs €0.65 and is worth €3.20 on the menu. €5 off the next bill costs €5. Then keep the total cost of rewards against what members spend in view.

What rewards do restaurant customers like most?

We have not measured which rewards diners prefer, so there is no figure to quote. What we can say is which are cheap to give: a dessert, a soft drink, a starter. Ask ten regulars which they would choose before you launch.

Is a discount a good loyalty reward?

It is simple to explain, and the most expensive per reward, because every euro off is a euro less. If you choose a discount, give it an end date and check that the card brings extra visits to pay for it.

Can I set any reward in Rewardly?

You name the reward on the card: a product, an add on, a gift. Rewardly counts the stamps or points and tells staff when a reward is ready. With a connected till (Advanced plan and above) the reward can free a chosen product. There are no time of day rules. The one time based option is the weekend double points toggle on points cards.

Choose your reward and set it up. Try Rewardly for €0

No upfront payment, 14 days free.

Share this article

Roman Osadský

Written by

Roman Osadský

Co-founder, Rewardly

Continue Reading