Skip to content
Back to Blog
Loyalty Tips

Loyalty program ideas for cafés and restaurants: 7 mechanics and what each costs

Loyalty program ideas for cafés and restaurants: 7 mechanics from stamps to VIP tiers, what each costs you in a worked example and how to choose one.

David Maroši
David Maroši13 min read
Loyalty program ideas for cafés and restaurants: 7 mechanics and what each costs

The best loyalty program ideas for a café or restaurant are seven mechanics: stamps, points, weekend double points, cashback, VIP tiers, a member discount, and gift cards or passes. A café with weekly regulars starts with stamps. A restaurant whose bills vary starts with points or cashback. Start with one. In the examples below the main mechanics cost you between 4% and 8% of what a member spends to earn the reward, and each section shows the sum, the sentence staff say and the Rewardly setting. With Rewardly it starts at €29.90 a month per location, and every plan has a 14 day trial (prices excluding VAT).

All prices, tickets and costs below are illustrative, so replace them with yours. For the sums behind the numbers of stamps and points, see how many stamps on a loyalty card.

1. Stamps: one per visit or per product

Fits: customers who come every week and buy one thing, such as a lunch bar, a bubble tea shop or a breakfast spot.

Staff scan the customer's card and add a stamp. When the last stamp goes on, the reward is ready at once and the card starts again, with any extra stamps carried over. You can give one stamp per visit or one per product. Stamp per visit or stamp per product shows when each is right. Stamps are in every plan.

Say a lunch bar sells a soup and sandwich lunch for €8.50 and it costs €3.20 to make. The card has 6 stamps and the reward is a free lunch.

  1. The customer pays 6 × €8.50 = €51.
  2. The free lunch costs you €3.20. €3.20 ÷ €51 = 6.3% of what they spent.
  3. A customer who lunches there three times a week fills the card in 2 weeks. One who comes once a week needs 6.

The downside: if the customer would have come anyway, you gave away the €8.50 menu price, not the €3.20. Stamps reward frequency, not a bigger bill, so a customer who always buys the cheapest item stays cheap.

Staff say: "Want our card on your phone? Six lunches and the seventh is on us."

2. Points: one reward at two prices

Fits: restaurants and any place where bills range from a coffee to a full table.

Customers earn points on every euro they spend. You choose 1 to 50 points per euro, and you can add as many rewards as you like at different points prices. Points come from the purchase amount: from a connected till, or typed by staff in the scanner. Points cards are in every plan.

Say a restaurant gives 10 points per €1 and an average bill is €25, so one visit earns 250 points. It has two rewards:

  1. Dessert at 300 points. 300 points is €30 spent. The dessert is on the menu at €6.50 and costs €1.90 to make: €1.90 ÷ €30 = 6.3%. After two visits (500 points) the customer has already earned one.
  2. Main course at 1,000 points. 1,000 points is €100 spent, four visits at €25. The main sells at €14 and costs €5.20: €5.20 ÷ €100 = 5.2%.

The two prices give a new member something at the second visit and a reason to keep going. A bigger bill brings the reward sooner without any extra rule for staff. The cost of confusion is real, though: if a member cannot tell how many points they have and what they buy, the card stops working. Show the two prices on the counter sign.

Staff say: "Scan your card and the points go on, ten for every euro. A dessert is 300."

3. Weekend double points

Fits: a place that is busy on weekdays and quiet on Saturday and Sunday, such as a lunch spot in an office district.

On a points card there is a weekend bonus: one switch and Saturdays and Sundays earn double points. Double stamp days can be set up on stamp cards too. For a promotion on a different day, announce it with a push message on the Advanced plan.

Say points cost you 6% of spend. At the weekend they cost 12%. Members spend €400 on Saturdays and Sundays in a month:

  1. Extra reward cost: 6% × €400 = €24 a month.
  2. A weekend bill is €22. At a 65% margin that is €22 × 0.65 = €14.30.
  3. €24 ÷ €14.30 = 1.7, so you need 2 extra weekend visits a month to cover it.

The downside: regulars who always came on Saturday are paid double for what they did anyway. If your weekends are already full, leave the switch off.

Staff say: "This weekend your points count double."

4. Cashback: credit that brings them back

Fits: restaurants with table service and a connected till, where a customer returns every few weeks.

A cashback card returns a percentage of every purchase as store credit. The customer comes back to spend it with you. At a connected till the credit can come off the bill; how this works in Storyous and Papaya POS is in paying with credit and cashback at the till, and the setup is in how to set up a cashback card in a restaurant.

Say a family restaurant returns 4% and the average bill is €32.

  1. One visit earns 4% × €32 = €1.28 in credit.
  2. A family that comes twice a month collects €2.56 a month.
  3. After 8 visits, about four months, that is €10.24, a main course or a dessert and a coffee.

The most it can cost you is 4% of members' spending, and only if every euro of credit is spent. Credit that is never spent costs nothing. The downside is the same as for any money back: if the customer would have paid €32 anyway, the credit is €1.28 you gave away. Check the percentage against your margin before launch.

Staff say: "Scan before I close the bill. Four percent comes back as credit for next time."

5. VIP tiers for your best regulars

Fits: a place with people who come several times a week.

A VIP card has 1 to 5 tiers. Customers move up on their own after a number of visits or an amount of lifetime spend, and each tier has its own percentage discount. The card can be open to everyone or by invitation only, with invites sent by email or as a private link. VIP cards are in every plan.

Rewardly's data says why it is worth a tier: in the typical business the top 20% of members make 65% of member visits (41,187 members of 60 businesses, October 2025 to September 2026; your top 20% of members). These customers come back without being asked, so a large discount mostly pays them for what they do anyway.

Say a regular has a €11 lunch three times a week, which is €33 a week and €1,716 a year. Silver comes after €150 of spend with 5% off, Gold after €500 with 10% off.

  1. Silver after about 4.5 weeks, Gold after about 15 weeks.
  2. Silver covers the spend from €150 to €500, which is €350: €350 × 5% = €17.50 in discounts.
  3. Gold covers the rest of the year, €1,716 minus €500 = €1,216: €1,216 × 10% = €121.60.
  4. Total: about €139, which is 8.1% of the €1,716 they spent.

Keep the top discount small, and add what costs nothing: a named tier, the first slice of a new dish, a table you hold. Launch tiers after the first card has run for a couple of months.

Staff say: "You are Gold now. Ten percent off from today."

6. A member discount card

Fits: a lunch trade with a fixed price, or a shop with a clear member price.

A discount card holds member only prices and offers on the customer's phone. It is the simplest idea to explain and the most expensive to run, because the discount comes off every sale, not just one visit in ten.

Say a weekday lunch is €9 and costs €3.30 to make. Members get 10% off.

  1. Without the discount the margin is €9 minus €3.30 is €5.70.
  2. With it, €8.10 minus €3.30 is €4.80.
  3. To keep the same total margin you need €5.70 ÷ €4.80 = 1.19, so 19% more member visits. Out of 100 visits you need 119.

It can still be right for a slow weekday or a stock you need to move, because the customer sees a lower price at once. Put an end on it: a discount with no end becomes the new price.

Staff say: "Members pay the card price, so ten percent less on the lunch."

7. Gift cards and passes

Fits: a restaurant or café that wants new customers and cash before the visit. Professional plan.

A gift card is prepaid credit you sell online. The buyer pays on your voucher page, which you can embed on your website, through your own Stripe account, and Rewardly takes no commission on voucher sales. The recipient gets the card by email and in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet. A pass is a set number of uses, for example 10 lunches, and the remaining uses show on the card. Only gift cards can be sent as a gift. You sell one gift card at a time.

Say a restaurant sells 20 gift cards of €40 before Christmas: €800 arrives before a single plate leaves the kitchen, and each recipient who has not been before is a customer you did not pay to find. Or a pass of 10 lunches at €76.50 instead of €85: the customer saves €8.50 and you hold €76.50 before the first visit.

The downside: you carry the open balances, and a pass given as a 10% discount is still a discount. Setup is in gift cards for small business, and the 10 visit pass compares paper and phone. If you only sell a few a year, a printed template from the free gift voucher maker is enough.

Staff say: "I take one lunch off your pass. You have six left."

What about referral?

Rewardly has a referral function, where a member brings a friend. It works as a second layer once one of the mechanics above is running, not as a first program. Ask the team how it fits your card before you plan around it.

The seven side by side

Mechanic

Best fit

What it costs in the example

Stamps

weekly regulars, one product

6.3% of spend

Points

varied bills

5.2% to 6.3%

Weekend double points

quiet weekends

12% on weekend spend, double the normal

Cashback

table service, connected till

up to 4%

VIP tiers

regulars several times a week

8.1% for a top regular

Member discount

fixed price lunch

10% of every sale, needs 19% more visits

Gift cards and passes

new customers, cash up front

pass at 10% below list price

How to choose in three questions

  1. How often do customers come? Every week: stamps. Every few weeks: points or cashback, because a stamp card of ten would take months to fill. How long a card takes is in how many stamps on a loyalty card.
  2. Do bills vary? A coffee at €3 and a table at €60 earn the same stamp. Points grow with the bill.
  3. What do you want to change? More visits: stamps. A bigger bill: points. Quiet weekends: the weekend bonus. A group of best regulars: a VIP card on top.

Pick one main mechanic and one supporting layer. Stamps with a VIP card, or points with the weekend bonus, are workable pairs. Stamps, points, discounts and VIP at once is four explanations at the till, and customers lose track of them. Which loyalty program is right for your business goes further.

Whatever you pick, let a new member see progress in the first month. In Rewardly's data of more than 40,000 loyalty cards across 50+ businesses, members who came back in their first full month were still visiting 10 to 12 months later 54.3% of the time, against 20.1% of those who did not (the retention study). That describes behaviour, not the effect of the card. Members who return at all typically do so after 15 days in coffee shops and 18 in restaurants (how soon members come back by industry), so a first reward that takes four months is out of sight.

To see how a card will look, design it in the free loyalty card maker. How the whole setup looks for a restaurant or a café is on the loyalty for restaurants and loyalty for coffee shops pages. Rewardly clients report 30% more repeat visits, but your own second visit rate is the number to manage.

When these ideas will not fit

  • Customers visit once a year or less. A stamp has nothing to count. Gift cards fit better.
  • The reward costs more than the visit earns. If your own sum comes out well above 8%, shorten the card or lower the reward.
  • The food or service is not what brings people back. A loyalty program will not rescue a long wait or a cold plate.

FAQ

What is the best loyalty program for a café?

Stamps, one per visit. The rule fits in one sentence, staff explain it in five seconds and weekly regulars fill a card in weeks. Add a VIP card for your best regulars once it runs.

What is the best loyalty program for a restaurant?

Points or cashback. Bills vary a lot in a restaurant, and both reward a bigger bill. With a connected till, staff scan the card before the bill closes.

Can I combine several mechanics?

Yes, but start with one main mechanic and one supporting layer. Four at once means four explanations at the till.

Do I need a till integration?

No. Stamps work with the scanner alone, which runs in a browser on a phone or tablet with nothing to install. For points and cashback staff type the purchase amount, or a connected till (Advanced plan and above) sends it.

How much should a loyalty reward cost me?

In the examples above the main mechanics cost between 4% and 8% of what members spend to earn the reward. Work out yours as the cost to make the reward divided by the spend that earns it.

Pick your mechanic and set it up. Try Rewardly for €0

No upfront payment, 14 days free.

Share this article

David Maroši

Written by

David Maroši

CEO, Rewardly

Continue Reading