Restaurant loyalty program: how to choose points, cashback or VIP and set it up
Restaurant loyalty program: points, stamps, cashback or VIP, with a lunch and a dinner example, the margin maths and how it works with your POS.

Which restaurant loyalty program pays off? For most restaurants it is a points program: the guest earns points from the bill (1 to 50 points per euro), spends them on rewards that have different prices, and the first reward is within reach by the second visit. A lunch place with one menu at one price can run on a stamp per visit. Cashback and a VIP card are add ons, not the starting point. In Rewardly's data, a restaurant member who comes back does so after a median of 18 days, so the reward has to arrive before the guest forgets you. What Rewardly offers restaurants is on the page for a restaurant loyalty program. This article is the setup guide.
A loyalty program for an independent restaurant in Europe
Most advice on restaurant loyalty is written for chains with their own app and a loyalty team. An independent restaurant in Europe needs something lighter: a card the guest keeps in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet, a till that records the visit without extra typing, and a reward you can afford at your margin. That is what the rest of this guide builds. For the short version of what Rewardly offers, see loyalty for restaurants.
Which model fits your restaurant
Model | Fits when | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
Stamp per visit | lunch at a similar price, guests who come often | dinner bills of different sizes, a stamp cannot tell them apart |
Points from the bill | bills from €12 to €80, lunch and dinner | the reward needs a margin calculation |
Cashback | you want to return part of the bill as credit for the next visit | the credit must be easy to spend at the till |
VIP card | a steady clientele that comes regularly | discounts come out of margin, see below |
The rule: pick one model, not three at once. A €10 lunch menu is a stamp. A €25 dinner is points. Cashback has its own guide in how to set up a cashback card in a restaurant. The VIP card is covered in how to introduce a digital membership card.
Lunch: a stamp per visit you can calculate
Illustrative figures, replace them with yours: a lunch restaurant, a menu at €10, a regular who comes twice a week. The card says "the tenth lunch is free".
- Out of ten lunches the guest pays 9 × €10 = €90. The tenth, worth €10, is free: €10 out of €100, or 10% of the price.
- Assume ingredients are 35% of the menu price. The reward costs you €3.50 in ingredients.
- Twice a week is 104 visits a year, about 10 rewards, which is €100 of revenue (€35 in ingredients) per regular.
The downside: if the guest would have come twice a week anyway, that €100 a year is a plain discount. The upside: the card turns two lunches a week into three. That is 156 visits with 16 free lunches. Paid lunches are 140 instead of 94, about 47 more: 47 × €10 = €470 of revenue a year from one guest. How to pick the number of stamps is in how many stamps to put on a loyalty card.
Lunch regulars: what 30 guests are worth in a year
A second look at the lunch card, this time for the whole room. The numbers are assumptions for illustration, not data from real restaurants. Assumptions: a €10 lunch menu, ingredients at 35% of the price, 30 regulars who come twice a week (104 visits a year) and a card where the tenth lunch is free. The table shows how many extra paid lunches each regular adds because of the card, which is the only thing that decides whether it pays.
Extra paid lunches per regular a year | Extra revenue, 30 regulars | Left after ingredients and extra free lunches | Advanced plan, 12 months |
|---|---|---|---|
12 (one more a month) | €3,600 | €2,130 | €598.80 |
24 (two more a month) | €7,200 | €4,365 | €598.80 |
47 (three lunches a week instead of two) | €14,100 | €8,535 | €598.80 |
The first row worked out: 12 extra lunches × €10 = €120 per regular. Ingredients on them are 35%, which is €42. The extra visits earn about two more free lunches than before, which cost about €7 in ingredients. €120 minus €42 minus €7 is €71, and 30 regulars × €71 = €2,130.
If the card changes nothing and the guest would have come anyway, you only give away the free lunch. Advanced costs €49.90 per location per month excluding VAT, which is €598.80 for 12 months, because the POS connection starts there. Replace every number with yours, or use the ROI calculator.
Stamps at the till: Storyous, Dotykačka, Portos and Papaya POS
If your till is Storyous, Dotykačka, Portos or Papaya POS, the stamp is added at the till. Staff scan the guest's card when they close the bill and the visit is recorded, so nobody punches a card or types a number. The connection comes with Advanced and above. For a lunch place with a queue at 12:30, that is the difference between a program offered to every guest and one skipped when it is busy. The setup is described on the Storyous integration page and the Dotykačka integration page. Without a POS, staff open the scanner in the browser and the guest still gets the stamp.
Dinner: points and a first reward at the second visit
In a restaurant the size of the bill varies. Points show it fairly: a guest who spends more earns more. Points always come from the amount of a purchase, not from a visit. You can have several rewards, each with its own price in points, and the guest spends points in the points shop.
Illustrative figures: an average bill of €25 per guest, a rule of 10 points per €1, so 250 points per dinner. The first reward, a dessert priced at €6 on the menu, costs 300 points.
- After the first dinner the guest has 250 points, after the second 500. The dessert is theirs at the second visit.
- Over two dinners they spend 2 × €25 = €50. A dessert worth €6 is 12% of that.
- The ingredients for the dessert cost about €1.80. In margin the reward costs you €1.80 out of €50, or 3.6%.
A dessert, a drink or a starter has a high menu price and a low kitchen cost, which makes this reward cheaper than a discount on the bill. The downside: if the guest would have come a second time anyway, the dessert cost you €1.80 in ingredients and €6 of revenue. Add bigger rewards above the first one with the same arithmetic.
What matters most is when the guest gets the first reward. In Rewardly's data (more than 40,000 cards, 50+ businesses), 39.5% of new members at restaurants and bistros come back within 30 days and 54.0% within 90. The typical time to the second visit is 18 days, and 3 in 4 returning members are back within 44 days. A reward that needs ten dinners is too far away for most guests. The study: how soon loyalty members come back by industry. The data counts scanned cards, so real rates are likely a little higher.
Connecting the till
Points and cashback are credited from the amount of the bill, a stamp per visit from the visit. You have two routes:
- No connection. Staff open the scanner in the browser on a phone or tablet (nothing to install, internet needed) and enter the bill amount for points.
- With a POS. A connection to Papaya POS, Storyous, Portos or Dotykačka comes with Advanced and above. Staff scan the card and the till supplies the bill amount. In Storyous, points are calculated from the amount actually paid after discounts.
Four things that are easy to miss:
- You cannot create a member at the till. The guest signs up through the QR code first and staff scan the card afterwards.
- In Storyous and Papaya POS, credit and cashback can pay part of the bill. In Storyous the credit is pre filled and the waiter can lower or remove it. In Papaya POS all available credit is used up to the bill amount. Details: paying with credit and cashback at the till.
- If Rewardly does not answer at that moment, Storyous and Papaya POS get an empty offer and you close the bill as usual, just without a reward. The till is never blocked, as explained in why a loyalty program must never block your till.
- How staff recognise the customer when scanning is in scanning a loyalty card at the till. The differences between tills are in Rewardly POS integrations compared. Storyous is described on its integration page.
How to get guests into the program
A guest signs up where they sit and wait for the bill. In Rewardly's data, 70% of people who arrived at the join page directly, for example through a QR code in the venue, became members, against 28% of those who came from Instagram. More in the study on QR code or Instagram. Put the QR code on the table and on the bill folder.
Staff need one sentence, said at payment:
"Would you like points for today's bill? Scan this code, it takes ten seconds and your second visit comes with a free dessert."
The card is added to Apple Wallet or Google Wallet in about 10 seconds and the guest downloads nothing.
What to do when a guest goes quiet
From Advanced you can build a reminder: after a visit the system waits the number of days you choose (1 to 365) and, if the guest has not come back, sends a message. It is a setup you build yourself, not a ready made automation. Timing from the data: 3 in 4 returns at restaurants happen within 44 days, so a message around day 30 to 40 reaches the guests who will not return on their own. A text: "Your dessert is still waiting on your card. Come by this week."
- Birthday message. It needs a date of birth in the sign up form, goes out on the morning of the birthday, and you write the text. More in birthday and name day messages.
- A weekend of double points. A points card has a switch for double points on weekends. It makes sense if your weekend is quiet, for example a lunch place in an office district.
- Regulars. In Rewardly's data, the top 20% of members made 65% of visits in the typical business (study). For them there is a VIP card with tiers by visits or spend.
Messages reach only customers who agreed to marketing. Rewardly measures a 90% read rate on wallet messages.
Four mistakes and the fix
- A reward too early for everyone. A discount on the first visit teaches guests to wait for a discount. Fix: a small first reward, at the second visit.
- Staff do not know what to say. If the program is only offered now and then, there are few members. Fix: one sentence at payment, and a look at the member count after two days.
- No numbers. Fix: after 30 days compare how many new members came back. For 200 members the yardstick is 39.5%, about 79 returns (an illustrative calculation, not a promise).
- Too many models. Fix: one model, the others only once the first one works.
What it costs and when it pays back
Basic costs €29.90, Advanced €49.90 and Professional €79.90 per location per month (prices excluding VAT). The card, the QR code and the scanner are in every plan, the POS connection and push notifications from Advanced. The first 14 days are a trial: you add a payment card at signup and nothing is charged.
Payback at a €25 bill (illustrative, replace with your own numbers): assume 70% of the bill is left after your costs, which is €17.50. Advanced costs €49.90, so €49.90 ÷ €17.50 = 2.85, which means three extra visits a month. Put your own numbers into the ROI calculator.
FAQ
How does a restaurant loyalty program work?
The guest adds the card to Apple Wallet or Google Wallet through a QR code. Staff scan it at payment, points or stamps are credited from the bill, and when the guest reaches a reward they take a dessert, a drink or a dish.
What rewards do restaurant guests value?
We have no data of our own on that. What works is a reward the guest would order anyway and that is cheap in the kitchen: a dessert, a drink, a starter. It must be within reach by the second or third visit.
Is cashback worth it for a restaurant?
It is when you want to bring the guest back with credit for the next visit and the till can use it at payment. The details are in the cashback guide above.
Does it work with my POS?
With Papaya POS, Storyous, Portos and Dotykačka on Advanced and above. Without a POS, staff enter the bill amount in the scanner in the browser.
Do guests need an app?
No. The card lives in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet. A phone without one of the two cannot save the card.
Launch your restaurant loyalty program. Try Rewardly for €0
No upfront payment, 14 days free.


